Full CRO Audit & Strategy | Optimize Your Conversions

1 Source: Freepik

A Conversion Rate Optimization (CRO) audit is essential for improving your website's performance and driving business growth. This systematic evaluation helps you identify bottlenecks, user frustrations, and untapped opportunities in your conversion funnel. 

Why CRO Audit is important 

By conducting a CRO audit, you gain valuable insights into user behavior, allowing you to make data-driven decisions that enhance the user experience and increase conversion rates. 

This process is crucial because even slight improvements in your conversion rate can lead to significant increases in revenue and customer satisfaction. 

When Can a CRO Audit be Done?

A CRO audit can be performed at various stages of a website's lifecycle, but it's important to note that timing plays a crucial role. Here's an explanation of when to conduct a CRO audit:

However, conducting a CRO audit too early can produce misleading results. A minimum of 1-3 months is typically needed to gather sufficient, statistically significant data. This waiting period ensures that user behavior and frustrations are genuine, leading to more accurate and valuable insights for optimization efforts.

The following nine steps provide a comprehensive framework for conducting an effective CRO audit. This process will equip you with valuable insights to optimize your website, increase conversion rates, and ultimately drive business growth.

9 Essential Steps for a Thorough CRO Audit

A well-executed CRO audit is crucial for unlocking your website's full potential and driving conversions. These steps will help you improve your website and boost its performance.

Step 1: Identify Critical Conversion Points

Before improving your website, you need to know what you want your visitors to do. These important actions are called "conversions."

For different businesses, conversions may vary:

• If you sell products, it might be when someone buys something.

• If you offer a service, it could be when someone signs up for a trial or demo.

  
  

Smaller steps towards conversions matter too, like:

• Adding items to a cart

• Signing up for a newsletter

• Watching a product video

  
  

Consult with your team to define what conversions mean for your business. This ensures an accurate depiction of your website's effectiveness.

Expert tip: To conduct a thorough CRO audit, examine your entire conversion funnel, from initial visit to final purchase. Identify where users drop off at each stage and look for improvement opportunities. Instead of solely focusing on increasing traffic, prioritize optimizing the existing user journey through your funnel.

Step 2: Prioritize Key Pages

Follow CRO best practices by running your audit on pages with the most potential to affect your conversions. Then narrow down your list of priority pages by considering how much traffic the page gets and where it fits in the user journey. 

Aim to audit pages that are both conversion-oriented and those with healthy traffic numbers to see results much quicker. This is how you determine whether your optimization efforts are headed in the right direction. 

Top-of-the-funnel (TOFU) content, which helps businesses create awareness about their product, usually gets a lot of traffic. However, they don't lead to direct conversions since it's positioned at the start of the customer journey. Therefore, TOFU is not a good main audit focus.  

Instead, prioritize pages that act as key touchpoints in the customer journey—like specific landing pages designed to convert. These types of pages can help you improve your conversion rate optimization (CRO) efforts.

Step 3: Understanding User Behavior

Source: searchenginepeople.com

After identifying your key conversion actions and priority pages, the next crucial step is to examine how visitors interact with your site. This analysis helps you determine whether users are converting and, more importantly, why they are or aren't.

Start with broad analytics:

• Use Google Analytics to track goal conversions

• Set up event tracking for key actions (like purchases or signups)

  
  

Then, dive deeper with specialized CRO Tools like:

By combining these tools, you'll get a clearer view of user behavior. This end-to-end analysis uncovers valuable insights about which elements of your site are helping or hindering conversions.

This then allows you to:

• Pinpoint exact drop-off points

• Identify frustration triggers

• Understand why some elements succeed while others fail

  
  

Armed with these insights, you can make data-driven decisions to optimize your site and improve conversion rates effectively.

Step 4: Capture Customer Voice Insights

Move beyond quantitative data in your CRO audit by gathering qualitative insights directly from your users. This step helps you understand their true motivations and obstacles.

You can use CRO tools with pop-up survey features to enhance your CRO audit.

For example, if you notice cart abandonment at checkout, ask users why they're leaving. Their responses might reveal:

• Navigation or search filter issues

• Concerns about shipping costs or delivery times

• Missing information that prevents purchase decisions

  
  

Key areas to explore with surveys:

• Product-market fit: Does your offering meet market needs?

• Exit intent: Why are users leaving your site?

• Pricing clarity: Is your pricing information sufficient and clear?

  
  

By incorporating these voice-of-customer insights, you can identify improvement areas that quantitative data alone might miss. This approach ensures your CRO efforts address real user needs and concerns, potentially leading to more effective optimizations.

Step 5: Spot Easy Improvements

Combine quantitative and qualitative data by tracking user actions and collecting feedback to understand user satisfaction, goals, and concerns, and identify barriers to conversion. Use the new CRO audit results to find and apply 'quick fixes' or simple changes to address frustrations on your page.

Consider this scenario: You're running paid campaigns for a downloadable resource. How complex is your form? User feedback might reveal that excessive personal information requirements are deterring downloads. A simple fix could involve trimming the form to essential fields only.

E-commerce operators should be vigilant about technical hiccups and checkout flow inefficiencies. Analyze session recordings of both completed purchases and abandoned carts. In addition, put yourself in the customer's shoes by going through the buying process to spot potential friction points.

Use this checklist to uncover additional quick improvements. Ensure your key pages include:

• An eye-catching headline

• Clear unique selling propositions

• High-resolution visuals

• Strategic use of negative space

• Credibility boosters (e.g., testimonials, reviews, case studies)

• Enticing offers (e.g., trial periods, guarantees)

• Accessible contact options

• Consistent and prominent calls to action

By addressing these elements, you can make swift enhancements to your conversion funnel.

Step 6: Create a Conversion Theory

For bigger product modifications, it is good to develop a precise, testable theory to have a rough idea of what changes will boost your conversion rates.

Make use of insights from your user and product analysis to pinpoint specific pages and website components that, when optimized, could better address user needs and drive sales.

Consider this scenario: You notice a crucial landing page has low engagement and high exit rates. When you dig deeper, you discover your message isn't striking a chord with your target audience. This leads to a theory: If we incorporate more relevant information for our target demographic, we might see an increase in this landing page's conversion rate by 2%.

Alternatively, if your demo scheduling page is underperforming, and user feedback shows hesitation because of unclear expectations about the demo process, you can safely conclude that: By putting clear information about the demo's length and format at the top of the page, we can expect to double our bookings.

These theories will serve as the foundation for your A/B testing strategy, which is the next phase.

Step 7: Execute the A/B tests

After creating all your precise theories, you can move on to the last phase of your audit, which is conducting A/B or split tests to evaluate their outcomes and make evidence-based CRO decisions.

Start by establishing clear metrics and objectives to measure your test outcomes. Use a reputable A/B testing platform to set up your experiments—popular choices include Google Optimize, Optimizely, VWO, or Omniconvert. 

You need to create a test variant and a control version, share the traffic evenly between them, and let the experiment run until you've gathered sufficient data to determine a winner.

You can also combine this with other CRO tools to delve deeper into your test results. This helps uncover the reasons behind user preferences for different page versions and provides insights into the full user journey across your site.

Below are some examples of how different teams might develop hypotheses and execute A/B tests:

Skull Shaver:

Batik Shirt:

By following this approach, you can systematically test and refine your conversion optimization strategies based on real user data and behavior.

Step 8: Apply Your Discoveries

Next, apply all your findings from your split tests, key page evaluations, and product experience (PX) research to your strategy.

If your theory was on point during the experiment, then you're set to implement the changes across the board.

However, if your optimization strategy falls short of expectations, collect additional user data and revisit your approach so you can come up with another theory.

Be sure to share your CRO audit findings with your team and key stakeholders. This ensures everyone is aligned with the priority areas for future optimization efforts.

Step 9: Plan Your Next CRO Audit

Conversion rate optimization is an ongoing process, not a one-off task.

Half a year from now, things might be different, especially with new players and offerings emerging. Your own business could have evolved too—perhaps you've introduced new web pages and features, or diversified into different market segments or industries.

Leading companies and websites are always evolving to meet new user needs and market challenges. To remain competitive, regularly perform CRO audits to align your site with internal changes and market shifts. These assessments will help you stay in tune with customers' needs, including new ways to improve their experience and equip them with everything needed to continue contributing to your conversion funnel.

Boost Conversions Through User-Focused CRO Audits

2 Freepik

Most customers are willing to pay more for great experiences. If your website doesn't offer this, you're missing out on sales.

Review your site with customers in mind. This helps you:

1. Understand what users really want

2. See which parts of your site work best

3. Test new ideas for improvement

A good review is the first step to solving customer problems and meeting your business goals.

CRO Audit FAQs

What is a conversion rate optimization audit?

A conversion rate optimization (CRO) audit is a systematic review of a website or app to identify opportunities for improving its ability to convert visitors into customers or leads. It involves analyzing user behavior, site performance, and design elements to pinpoint areas that may be hindering conversions and develop strategies to enhance the user experience and increase conversion rates.

When should I do a CRO audit?

Conduct a CRO audit regularly, ideally every 6-12 months, or when significant changes occur in your business, website, or market. This includes after major site updates when entering new markets, or if you notice declining conversion rates. Regular audits ensure your site remains optimized for current user needs and business goals.

How long should a CRO audit run for?

A CRO audit typically runs for 4-8 weeks, depending on the complexity of the website and the depth of analysis required. However, the exact duration can vary based on factors like site traffic volume, the number of pages being audited, and the specific goals of the audit.